Tuesday, November 3, 2015

Independent Reading for Narration in Year 2

SA(7) is reading quite well now. Ambleside Online's booklist for year two is still mostly too advanced for him to read on his own, and I read most of them aloud to him. However, I have given him two books this term that he reads independently, and then comes and narrates to me. These two books are Holling C. Holling's Tree in the Trail and The Burgess Animal Book for Children. The language in these books (particularly Burgess) is relatively simple.

I am still keeping the lessons where he does this very short at ten minutes, but I am hoping to stretch them to fifteen or even twenty minutes by the end of the year. He is doing extremely well. He actually does a better job of narrating these books than the ones I read aloud to him. This may partly be because they are easier books, but I suspect it is also partly that his learning style is more visual than auditory. There is also a little bit of excitement in the fact that he feels like he is telling me something I might not know (since it's not something I just read aloud to him...).

I have also tried having him listen to Librivox and read along for some of his more difficult readings (The Little Duke). I am not particularly happy with that option, as I often feel like I could read it so much better to him myself, even with the French pronunciations. He likes the novelty of the audiobook experience, though, so we do it for variety sometimes.

Because of the very short lessons, we are "falling behind" on the Burgess Animal Book for Children...we are just not keeping up with the Ambleside Online schedule for it. However, he is enjoying it so much, owning it, really (this is his book to read and narrate from), that I'm not eager to jump in and help him move through it faster by reading some of it aloud. So we'll just continue at a comfortable pace. No doubt we'll speed up a little before the year is through.

Fellow CM homeschoolers, how do you transition from reading aloud to independent reading for narration? Is it a gradual process for you, or do you begin all at once at a certain point? I assume the time a child is ready varies widely from child to child. I'd love to hear your experience.

Comments (2)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
Ohhhh... I love the Burgess books. They're so sweet. My (nearly) 8 yo still enjoys them, and my 4 yo is *just* starting to sit and listen too.

My daughter has started doing some of the readings on her own and then narrating them back to me. I actually felt kind of sad about it - I love our books and I hate to be missing out on the stories. At the same time, I can NOT keep up with doing all the readings, so this is a good thing. Right now, all of her independent readings are short (from Just So Stories by Rudyard Kipling), but soon she'll be doing chapters from Five Children and It, then the Jungle Book and Pinocchio. My plan is to have her follow along while listening to the audiobooks because I know she'll be overwhelmed doing the full readings on her own.

I prefer the audiobooks from our library over Librivox. They're just so much better, and there are a ton that we can download from home (especially the classics). I also have a subscription to audiobooks.com and another one to scribd.com - I might have a slight audiobook addiction LOL.
Oh, I would never give up reading Just So Stories aloud. They're so much fun that way! :) I see I have some exploration to do in the world of audiobooks. I will check my library today.

Post a new comment

Comments by